Carly Smithson Controversy?

Were there really some controversies about Carly Smithson being eliminated? Read some news about her just now in the net, about her having a recording contract some years back....and a few other reasons why she was being eliminated eventhough she received positive comments from the judges this week.

One of the reasons was because of the t-shirt printed words say "Simon Cowell loves me ... this week" ...... She showed off that t-shirt the minute after Simon praised her performance for the night..

Well, I dont really fancy Carly too, perhaps I am too biased, the tattoos are too much for me, I guess I am too outdated to accept tattoos and stuff like that... I still bet on David A.... He is still my favourite... and I really hope he will be American Idol....